I’ve been mulling over some thoughts on the HCG Protocol for a while; thoughts that are less about the mechanics of the Protocol, and more about how people approach it. I have a good friend who’s on it and I know a few other people who know others who are on it. So within two degrees of separation, I’m hearing reports of how people are doing, and what they’re doing while on HCG, from about a half-dozen peeps on the Protocol.
I also got an e-mail from a blog reader who has a friend who was extremely successful on the Protocol, but who has since gained all of her weight lost back again (and guess what? I’m sure it brought friends. Cuz it always does, dammit.) Of course, then I read an article like this one, which cites the extremely high maintenance rate of those who lose using HCG (60-70%) over those who lose using other methods (10% or less). And I’m left to wonder, as many of you may be, what is the truth?
What is the “best” way to lose weight?
Is HCG the “magic bullet” that we’ve been waiting for?
You already know my answer to that; at least, if you’ve followed my blog for any length of time or know me personally at all, you do. Of course it’s not a “magic bullet.” As Oprah has said, if a magic cure for obesity/overweight existed, believe me when I tell you I’d have found it by now! And used it! No matter the cost! (Okay, that’s not really true, but it makes for pretty good reading, doesn’t it??)
The bottom line is that like all other diets (yes, I hate that word too, please don’t blast me for using it in this context), HCG is simply a tool to take off excess weight. It does a little bit extra for many of us, in that it also allows your body to reset the hypothalamus. Whassat you say?? In layman’s terms (cuz that’s what I am people – a layman…or woman…but laywoman doesn’t sound entirely…appropriate…but I digress): using the HCG Protocol allows your body to (a) shed excess weight that it may have been resistant to shedding before and (b) fix some of the damage we’ve done to our bodies (or some pre-existing dysfunction) with yo-yo dieting by resetting it’s “set point.” (“The set-point theory essentially argues that an individual’s metabolism will adjust itself to maintain a weight at which it is comfortable.” Click here for source & to read more.)
So, yeah, it makes sense then, if you believe that HCG operates in this way, that maintaining weight loss is slightly “easier” for those who use HCG as their tool. But that does not mean that maintenance is easy; that you can eat whatever you want and not gain weight. Maintenance is a life-long work that we all have to participate in. It will look different for each of us. But there are common threads: commitment to eating healthy. Balance/moderation/harmony in how we approach food and exercise. Mindfulness. And yes, that dreaded word…WORK.
I’m very frustrated when I hear of people who think HCG is a magic cure-all or easy fix; who don’t follow the Protocol and then bitch (sorry, I’m not sorry) about not losing weight. Or whine about not keeping the weight off. Who think that this is the magic pill we’ve all been dreaming of our whole lives. That pill doesn’t exist, friends. And guess what? One way in which the Protocol is exactly like other diets is that if you don’t follow the “rules,” it won’t work for you in the long run.*
Think about it. Calorie counters? If you throw counting to the wind and/or ignore what your calorie range should be for weight loss (or maintenance), how long will you continue losing/maintaining? Weight Watchers; if you ignore your points range and just eat what you want, what happens? South Beachers, if you start sneaking too many simple carbs into your plan, how well does that work for you? Whatever your program or diet or tool or whatever of choice, it likely only works if you actually…you know…follow it.
By the same token, if you ignore the Protocol; cheat while on Phase 2; eat like a madwoman once you’re back to “normal” eating (I never say I’m going back to my old “normal” eating habits – I’m moving on to healthy eating habits!); sneak a drink (or three) at a party while you’re on the low-calorie phase of the Protocol…one of three things will happen:
(1) You will not lose weight;
(2) You will gain weight; or
(3)You will lose weight, think you dodged the bullet, and at some point in the future (probably when you’re trying to stabilize at your new, lower weight) it will come back to bite you in the ass.
Just as with anything else in life, our decisions and our actions have consequences. Don’t pretend that just because your weight loss tool of choice is HCG, that rule of the universe does not apply to you. No matter what tool you are using to lose excess weight, know that you still have to do the work. The physical work. Following the plan. Also, the mental/emotional work that will allow you exist in a healthy-weight body without freaking out every time you look in the mirror because you feel like you’re seeing a stranger.
You gotta do the work, people. Bottom line.
Thoughts? I’d love to hear what y’all think about this stuff.
*This post is not intended to bash anyone who is struggling to follow-through, whether you’re on HCG or WW or PCP…oops, I mean, you know what I mean. I get that it is hard sometimes. Hell, I spent the better part of two decades struggling, doing well, stumbling, falling on my face, and getting back up again. This post isn’t about the struggle. This post is about trying to “game the system” and being pissed off when that doesn’t work.



Recent Comments